Is Bitcoin a Scam? No, But it Is a Fad That Has Already Peaked

Last Updated on by Jeremy

Disclaimers: Living the Dream uses demographic data, email opt-ins, display advertising, and affiliate links to operate this site. Please review our Terms and Conditions for more information. Listed prices and attraction details may have changed since our visit and initial publication.

In the last few years, the hot topic has been Bitcoin. Record Bitcoin values, Bitcoin billionaires, how to invest in Bitcoin, Bitcoin, Bitcoin, Bitcoin.

Everyone and their grandmother were talking about Bitcoin for a while, and you'd think we cured cancer with the amount of buzz that cryptocurrencies are generating.

But as I fancy myself more of a traditionalist when it comes to investing, I have adopted the view that not only is Bitcoin a bubble, but that it is a fad (and possibly an outright scam).

Proponents tout it as the greatest transfer of wealth the world has ever seen, and my follow up question is, yes, but whose wealth?

The following is why I'm not jumping onto the bandwagon.

The following is meant to be commentary, and is not investment advice. At publication I have no vested interest in any cryptocurrency.

Bitcoin is Not Acting as A Currency

Bitcoin is Digital Money

At its core, Bitcoin is simply a digital currency that is supposed to be independent of government influence, be faster to transmit, be much more secure to use, and so on.

It sounds great, no really it does, but if Bitcoin is supposed to be a currency, why aren't people using it as a currency? 

The rapid rise in Bitcoin's price is not because people are using it as currency, but rather for speculation for its future worth.

This is fine if you want to look at it from that perspective, but for the currency argument to work there has to be a relatively steady value such that if you go out to buy a computer with Bitcoin, the computer will be worth the same number of Bitcoins the next day, and the next day, and the next.

If the goalpost changes too quickly you have no incentive to go buy that computer now because you may get a better deal tomorrow. Or if you wait a week, you may end up being able to buy three computers for the same exact exchange.

In a way, this is one of the benefits of federal regulations as they help stave off rapid inflation (or deflation, as Bitcoin is experiencing). We enjoy a relatively stable currency because life as we know it demands it.

Unfortunately, what is going on right now is that people are speculating what the ultimate value Bitcoin will be, and hoping that a purchase of a coin today will have greater value in their own currency tomorrow.

If Bitcoin were to stabilize and start to act like a real currency many of the current investors will get out- and I don't have to spell it out for you what would happen to the price once that happens.

The greed of today's investors could be Bitcoin's undoing.

Blockchain Technology is Not Greater than the Sum of the Parts

Now is roughly the point where people begin to move away from the currency topic and tout the merits of the underlying technology (of both Bitcoin and other cryptocurrency).

It will revolutionize life as we know it and that is the value!

I'm going to concede this one as it is not entirely wrong. But to me there is a problem and that lies with the value of that market.

Speculators believe Bitcoin could go to $100,000 a coin or even $1,000,000 a coin, which if you do the math over the 21 million total coins that will be mined means that Bitcoin (and all corresponding crypto, by extension) would be worth more than all markets they service, worth more than all USD, worth more than all gold, and so on.

In fact, if Bitcoin hits $1,000,000 per coin, the total value of all coins mined would be worth more than the entire NYSE.

Are you kidding me? Oh, you're serious? Well, I'm going to call it and say that you can't do math.

Bitcoin and other similar crypto isn't being used as a currency, so let's get over the dream that it will be worth more than actual currencies of today. Likewise, the underlying technology is also only a small subset of the industries it services, so let's also get over the idea that it will be worth more than the sum total of the industries themselves.

It will definitely help those industries become more valuable, and thus will become valuable by association, but like everything else it is hard to become greater than the sum of the parts- and that is what people want it to become.

As I mentioned at the start of this one, I will concede that the technology is there to change the way many companies do business. But if you look at the way Bitcoin is valued, and where people project it to go, the math just falls apart.

In my opinion the people who circulate these figures are the ones who got in later and are hoping for another meteoric rise that will make them billionaires like it is doing for the initial investors who got in when the currency was worthless.

This brings me to my final point, and is one those people passing fuzzy math aren't going to like.

Who Do You Think You're Buying Your Bitcoin From?

Up until this point I've tried to convey my thoughts on the current state of Bitcoin, but there is one tangential view I want to take, and that is about the act of buying Bitcoin.

It has already been established that there will be no more than 21,000,000 Bitcoins ever created. It has also been established that roughly half of all available Bitcoins (as of late 2017) were mined in 2013 or earlier, when Bitcoin was under $100 per coin.

Going further, some initial investors have been coming out of the woodwork saying they've bought hundreds of thousands back then, and the anonymous inventor is rumored to have around a million in a stash for himself as well (a cool $15 billion and solid 6% of all Bitcoin mined as of publication of this article).

So if Bitcoin is of a finite quantity, and most all the coins were mined years ago, have you ever stopped to think who you're buying from?

Odds are good you're not buying from a miner who extracted a coin, is selling for face value, and is being rewarded for their effort.

In fact, the odds are in your favor that you're buying from an initial investor who is reaping a 10,000%, 100,000%, or even greater return on their investment through you.

Are these people billionaire investors? Drug dealers? Foreign governments? Hackers? Our own government? A 12 year old? No one really knows because, again, there are no regulations to track it.

Heck, I wouldn't be surprised if Bitcoin was created by a government as a way to become the dominant international currency. If their country can't be number one, why not create one that can? At that point it'd pretty much be the same thing.

What would you think if it came out that Satoshi was an operative of a government agency that created (and holds a major stake in) Bitcoin itself? Would you care? Will we ever find out?

These are things to think about that no one wants to talk about.

But more to the topic at hand, as you are not buying Bitcoin to use as currency, and are not utilizing it for its underlying technology for alternative value, what you have left is the hope that someone else is going to come along later to buy your coin for more.

Everyone is rushing in to buy Bitcoin at the moment but that also means that the opposite is true- someone is selling theirs, and they're doing it in large numbers.

At the end of the day what I could easily see happening is the initial investors getting out of Bitcoin (and putting very real money in their pockets) and recent buyers are left with an overpriced piece of code. A piece of code they don't understand, a piece of code no one wants to buy, and a piece of failed currency no business is willing to accept.

I don't have to remind you what will happen to the price when that happens- but it won't be stability.

Cryptocurrency is the Furby of the 2010s

Does everyone remember the Furby* craze of the late 1990s? The mad dash for Bitcoin right now reminds me a lot of that.

Furby was a dumb toy that came out in the late 1990s that instantly became the “it” toy everyone wanted for their kids. Supply was low and interest was high such that people would buy and resell the toys on Ebay for hundreds of times more than they were worth.

Replace the keywords above with Bitcoin in the late 2010s, and the description is eerily similar.

But what happened to Furby? Cut to a year or two later (heck, a few months later, even) and everyone had a Furby, they were saturated in the market, and they had little to no residual value.

I truly believe Bitcoin is following this path right now.

But where Furby was just a toy and had no value at the end of the day other than what value a toy can bring, I do believe Bitcoin could have residual value when its all said and done.

The billion dollar question for anyone thinking of investing is, naturally, what is that value?

Is Bitcoin worth $500 a coin? $1,000? $10,000? $20,000? Your guess is as good as anyone's, and that is precisely the problem with cryptocurrency today. It is all a guess.

To me the math for Bitcoin hitting $100,000 a coin or $1,000,000 a coin simply isn't there, and that means we're in speculation territory similar to the Furby craze of the late 1990s. We may not have hit peak yet, but at some point that price is going to come crashing down.

Again, I could be completely wrong on the above, but the fact that the price of Bitcoin is based on future worth makes it akin to gambling. When it comes to gambling, I'd rather spend $10 to make $100,000 than spend $10,000 to make $100,000 when the very real alternative is losing it all.

And if I'm going to lose it all, I'd rather just go on a vacation with that initial $10,000.

In fact, I think I will.

This post is meant to be a commentary on one person's perspective into Bitcoin's value. I have no monetary interests in crypto and this is not meant to be investment advice in the slightest. I could be right. I could be wrong. Either way, I'll be interested in seeing how this one plays out from the sidelines until I actually see the true value beyond the current fad.

*– After publishing this article I found out that others have referred to Bitcoin as the digital Furby as well. I was unaware of this comparison prior to writing this article.

Comments have been closed on this post as it has become a hot spot for insecure Bitcoin fans to try and justify their “investment” and prove me wrong (often with slurs and namecalling and not facts and logic). If you are wanting to do the same, I get that you lost your life's savings and need to convince other people to invest to recoup your money. But let's be honest here, we all saw that coming.

4 thoughts on “Is Bitcoin a Scam? No, But it Is a Fad That Has Already Peaked”

  1. Bitcoin is up about 150% since Jan 2019. It’s a fad but u have mainstream people taking it seriously. U are so off base.

    • No. No mainstream person is taking Bitcoin seriously. It is only the speculators and the people who lost their life’s savings investing at peak who still care (read: those already invested). Let me repeat. Bitcoin is not a currency. As long as its not a currency, no one will or should care.

  2. Glad you put some objective thought into this and laid out a solid case, until dipping into conspiracy theories and weaving rhetoric. Agreed on nearly all points, except that you have neglected to include one undeniable statistical fact: Millenials are not buying gold, stocks or bonds, like our parents did. We are buying, storing and exchanging bitcoin daily. Nearly 70% of all Millenials in the UK and USA use crypto wallets. Craigslist sales, house rentals, vacations, concert tickets, clothing and even yes, good quality recreational drugs tested and rated by a vast community, are all transacted with Bitcoin, Ethereum and Litecoin, Monero etc. Regardless of what anyone thinks of bitcoin, it is here to stay, and is now recognized as a store of value. Changes are coming, as this will be the first year that institutional money flows into the market. Get in now while you still can at low prices. Why not chance 10% of your portfolio to 5 crypto assets, send them to a hardware wallet and lock it up/forget about it for 10 years. The worst thing that could happen is you forget about that 10% you lost 10 years ago, and the best thing that could happen is that you remember, and then cash in for an early retirement.

    • This is pretty awful advice, and sounds like you mostly want more people to invest in Bitcoin in order to better your position (as is the case with most crypto fans out there). Most Millennials don’t even have money to invest, let alone have money to blow on a gamble that is Bitcoin- and I say this as a fellow Millennial.

      If you want to bet 10% of your income today, you’ll have better odds in Vegas. Also, I’m waiting on you to prove the “statistical fact” in your comment.

Comments are closed.

shares